Topics in this domain

Control Frameworks: NIST SP 800-53, CIS Controls and ISO 27002

Frameworks and policies · 2 min read

From outcomes to controls

Domain 1’s frameworks (NIST CSF, ISO 27001 and COBIT) describe what security must achieve and how to manage it. Control catalogues answer the next question: which specific safeguards? “Industry standards and frameworks for information security” is a named Domain 3 topic.

The main catalogues

ISO 27002, NIST SP 800-53, CIS Controls v8 and PCI DSS v4 compared by structure and best use.
CatalogueStructureBest for
ISO/IEC 27002:202293 controls in four themes: organisational, people, physical, technologicalOrganisations running an ISO 27001 ISMS
NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5Over 1,000 controls and enhancements in 20 families, with low, moderate and high baselinesUS federal agencies and suppliers; very detailed programs
CIS Controls v818 controls and about 150 safeguards, prioritised into implementation groupsA practical, prioritised starting point, especially for smaller organisations
PCI DSS v412 requirements for protecting cardholder dataAnyone storing, processing or transmitting card data

CIS implementation groups

CIS IG1 essential hygiene, IG2 for organisations with IT staff, IG3 all safeguards.
  • IG1: essential cyber hygiene, a minimum set every organisation should have.
  • IG2: adds safeguards for organisations with IT staff and more sensitive data.
  • IG3: all safeguards, for organisations facing sophisticated attackers.

Mapping one control to many requirements

Most organisations face several frameworks at once. Mapping each internal control to the frameworks it satisfies avoids duplicate work and shows coverage:

Internal controlISO 27001 / 27002NIST CSF 2.0CIS v8PCI DSS v4
Periodic access review5.18 Access rightsPR.AA5 and 6 (account and access management)7.2.4
MFA for remote access8.5 Secure authenticationPR.AA6.48.4.3

Choosing and using a catalogue

  • Start from the risk assessment and the organisation’s obligations.
  • Use CIS IG1 as a quick baseline if the program is immature.
  • Use ISO 27002 if running an ISO 27001 ISMS.
  • Use NIST SP 800-53 where regulation or customers require it.
  • Map everything to one internal control set.

Example. A healthcare company must meet HIPAA, a customer’s ISO 27001 requirement and PCI DSS for its payment desk. It builds one internal control library mapped to all three, so one access review produces evidence for every assessor.

How the exam asks about it

If the question asks…The answer is usually…
Prioritised controls for a small organisationCIS Controls (IG1)
Detailed US federal control catalogueNIST SP 800-53
Guidance supporting ISO 27001 Annex AISO/IEC 27002
Benefit of mapping frameworksOne control set meets several requirements
How controls should be selectedBased on risk, not by implementing everything

In short

  • Control catalogues list specific safeguards; governance frameworks (NIST CSF, ISO 27001, COBIT) say what to achieve and how to manage it.
  • ISO/IEC 27002 gives guidance on 93 controls in four themes, matching ISO 27001 Annex A.
  • NIST SP 800-53 is a very detailed catalogue (20 families) with low, moderate and high baselines, used widely by US government and its suppliers.
  • The CIS Controls (v8) are 18 prioritised controls with implementation groups IG1 to IG3; IG1 is essential hygiene for everyone.
  • Industry standards such as PCI DSS add mandatory requirements for specific data.
  • Mapping catalogues to each other avoids duplicate work and shows coverage of several requirements at once.

Exam traps

  • Implementing a whole catalogue without risk-based selection wastes effort.
  • ISO 27002 is guidance; certification is against ISO 27001.
  • CIS IG1 is a starting point, not the finish line, for organisations with significant risk.
  • Control catalogues don't replace a risk assessment; they help answer it.

Slides

Click the slide and use the arrow keys. F toggles full screen.

CISM · Domain 3 · Frameworks and policies

Control Frameworks: NIST SP 800-53, CIS Controls and ISO 27002

The detailed control catalogues a security manager uses to build the program, how they differ, and how to map them so one control set meets several obligations.

1 / 9