Topics in this domain

The Risk Assessment Process

Risk analysis · 2 min read

Why assess risk?

Resources are always limited. A risk assessment tells the security manager, and the business, which risks matter most, so money and effort go where they reduce the most risk. It’s the foundation for the strategy, the program and every treatment decision.

The steps

Scope and criteria, identify and value assets, threats and vulnerabilities, existing controls, likelihood and impact, evaluate and record.
  1. Scope and criteria: what’s in scope; the agreed likelihood and impact scales; the risk appetite.
  2. Identify and value assets: information, systems and processes, and their value to the business. Owners provide the value.
  3. Threats and vulnerabilities: what could happen, and which weaknesses it could exploit.
  4. Existing controls: what’s already in place, and whether it actually works.
  5. Likelihood and impact: analyse each risk scenario, qualitatively or quantitatively.
  6. Evaluate and record: compare with appetite, rank, and record in the risk register.

The results are then communicated to risk owners and management for treatment decisions.

Who takes part

ParticipantContributes
Business and risk ownersAsset value, business impact, acceptance of results
IT and system ownersSystems, dependencies, existing controls
Security teamThreats, vulnerabilities, method, facilitation
Legal, compliance, privacyObligations and penalties
Internal auditFindings as evidence, without owning the assessment

When to assess

  • Periodically: at least yearly for the enterprise view, more often for critical systems.
  • On change: new systems, cloud migrations, acquisitions, new suppliers, reorganisations.
  • On new threats: a new attack technique or an exploited vulnerability relevant to the organisation.
  • After incidents: an incident shows a risk was underestimated or a control failed.

Example. Before moving HR to a SaaS platform, the security manager runs a focused assessment with the HR director: assets (personal and salary data), threats (account takeover, supplier breach), existing controls (single sign-on, the supplier’s SOC 2 report) and impact (privacy fines, staff trust). Two risks exceed appetite, so MFA and a data-export alert are added before go-live.

How the exam asks about it

If the question asks…The answer is usually…
First step in a risk assessmentIdentify and value the assets
Who determines business impact?The business / asset owner
When should risk be reassessed?Periodically and on significant change
Main output of a risk assessmentPrioritised risks for treatment decisions
What comes before selecting controls?Assessing the risk

In short

  • A risk assessment identifies, analyses and evaluates risks so the organisation can decide how to treat them.
  • The key steps: scope and criteria, identify and value assets, threats and vulnerabilities, existing controls, likelihood and impact, evaluate and record.
  • Identifying and valuing assets comes first; business owners provide the value and impact.
  • Assessments are done periodically and whenever significant change happens: new systems, acquisitions, new threats, incidents.
  • Business owners, IT, security and others take part; risk owners must agree the results.
  • The output is a prioritised set of risks, recorded in the risk register, that drives treatment decisions.

Exam traps

  • Selecting controls before assessing risk is the wrong order.
  • An annual assessment alone isn't enough when the environment changes significantly.
  • Impact is judged by the business, not estimated by IT alone.
  • Existing controls must be checked for effectiveness, not just listed.

Slides

Click the slide and use the arrow keys. F toggles full screen.

CISM · Domain 2 · Risk analysis

The Risk Assessment Process

The steps of an information security risk assessment, who should take part, how often it's done and what it produces for the security manager and the business.

1 / 9